Students find that one fixed pulley changes only the direction of a pull, add ropes until 150 N lifts a 400 N sack, work out the pull (load ÷ supporting ropes) and the rope pulled (height × ropes), see that work in equals work out, choose a system for a brief and write a brief that needs four ropes.
Load these into Waypoints Prepare: choose Load URL and paste the copied address, or download the file and import it. In Prepare, the worksheet's Teacher edition shows the answers; the student copy hides them.
SlidesDownload Present from the browser, or export to PowerPoint or PDF.
WorksheetDownload Print the student copy; the Teacher edition has the answers.
Students will be able to
I can explain that one fixed pulley changes the direction of a pull, not its size.
I can work out the pull and the rope pulled by counting the ropes that hold the load up.
I can explain that a pulley system's work in equals its work out.
I can choose the fewest pulleys that meet a brief.
Timing
Predict and Try 8 min · Worked example 12 min · Vary 10 min · Practise and Make 15 min
Before class
Do Levers first: the Practise match ties gears, levers and pulleys together as one trade.
A pair of broom handles and a rope makes a striking demonstration: wrap the rope between them 3 or 4 times and one student can pull two others together.
Simplifications: no friction, and the pulleys, blocks and rope weigh nothing. Real systems lose a lot to friction, so they need more ropes than the model says.
Curriculum hooks: Design and Technologies, engineering principles and systems (primary); Science, forces and simple machines (Year 7), energy and work (Year 8–9); Maths, multiplication and division.
Running the lesson
Predict: most students choose 200 N. After the Try, ask why one pulley did not help.
Try: ask students to count the rope they pulled before the note appears.
Worked example: trace each rope with a finger and ask: does this one hold the block up?
Find the mistake: Mia's fifth rope goes over the top block. Point at where it is tied.
Vary: link the fixed pulley back to the idler gear: direction, not size.
Make: compare briefs; whose load ÷ pull ratio is closest to 4?
The hard part (on purpose)
Students count the rope they pull as a supporting rope, and expect any pulley to help. Ask 'does this rope hold the bottom block up?' for every rope.
When students get stuck
What you will see
A question to ask
The fix
A student counts the rope they pull.
Does this rope hold the bottom block up, or does it go over the top?
Count only the ropes between the blocks.
A student thinks one pulley halves the pull.
How many ropes hold the sack up?
One rope: the whole load. A fixed pulley only turns the pull round.
A student thinks more ropes means less work.
How much rope did you pull, and with what force?
Pull × rope pulled = load × height, whatever the number of ropes.
Answers to the checks
one pulley: One pulley at the top, and the rope goes from the sack, over the pulley and down to your hand. To lift the 400 N sack you pull… 400 N. One fixed pulley changes the direction of the pull (you can pull down, using your weight), not its size.
One rope: With one rope holding the sack, press Pull.
It does not move: one rope holds the whole 400 N, and you can pull only 150 N.
Add ropes: Add ropes (more pulleys) until your 150 N lifts the sack. Use as few as you can.
Three ropes: each holds 400 ÷ 3 ≈ 133 N, and 133 N is less than 150 N. Two ropes would each need 200 N.
Rope pulled: With 3 ropes, how much rope did you pull to lift the sack 1 m (in metres)? 3 3 m: each of the three ropes holding the block shortens by 1 m, and all of that rope comes out through your hands.
Four ropes, then six: 6 ropes hold up the bottom block, and the load is 600 N. What pull lifts it, in newtons? 100 600 ÷ 6 = 100 N.
Rope: With those 6 ropes, how much rope do you pull to lift the load 2 m, in metres? 12 6 × 2 = 12 m. Work in: 100 N × 12 m = 1200 J. Work out: 600 N × 2 m = 1200 J.
Find the mistake: Mia thinks she needs only 80 N. Click the line where Mia's working first goes wrong. line 2 Line 2: the rope she pulls goes over the top block, so it does not hold the bottom block up. Four ropes share the load: 400 ÷ 4 = 100 N, and she pulls 4 m.
Fewest ropes: A 900 N engine, and you can pull 200 N. Lift it with as few ropes as you can (fewer ropes means less rope to pull).
900 ÷ 200 = 4.5, so 5 ropes: 180 N each. 4 ropes would need 225 N.
Why one pulley?: If one fixed pulley does not make the pull smaller, why use one? It changes the direction: you can pull down, using your own weight, instead of lifting up Like an idler gear, a fixed pulley changes the direction, not the size. Flagpoles, curtains, and the top pulley of every block and tackle do this.
Pull: 3 ropes hold up a 750 N load. What pull lifts it, in newtons? 250 750 ÷ 3 = 250 N.
Rope: A crane's hook hangs on 8 ropes. To raise the hook 5 m, how much rope does the winch wind in, in metres? 40 8 × 5 = 40 m.
Trade-off: Which uses less rope to lift a 600 N load 2 m: 3 ropes or 6 ropes? 3 ropes: 6 m of rope instead of 12 m, but a 200 N pull instead of 100 N Rope = ropes × height. Fewer ropes: more pull, less rope.
Same idea everywhere: Each mechanism trades one thing for another. Match each to what it gives up to make your force bigger. Gears, small driving big → C. Speed of the output; Lever, pivot near the load → B. Distance your hand moves; Block and tackle → A. Length of rope you pull All three make your force bigger, and all three make you move farther or faster by the same factor: work in equals work out.
Four ropes: Set a load and your pull so that 4 ropes is the fewest that works. Then choose 4 ropes and lift.
The load ÷ your pull is more than 3 and no more than 4: 4 ropes is the fewest that works.
Solutions
One possible solution for each task. Other correct programs are fine.
Vary: choose a system › Fewest ropes
Open task: any program that does what the step asks.
Vary: choose a system › Why one pulley?
Open task: any program that does what the step asks.
a brief that needs four ropes › Four ropes
Open task: any program that does what the step asks.
a brief that needs four ropes › Evaluate
Open task: any program that does what the step asks.
Stretch and support
Stretch: Each pulley wheel loses about 5% of the force to friction. With 4 ropes (and so 4 wheels), roughly what pull lifts the 400 N sack now?
Support: Give a table with columns ropes, pull, rope pulled for 1 m, work in, and fill the 1-rope and 2-rope rows together.
Exit ticket
5 ropes hold up a 1000 N load. What pull lifts it, and how much rope do you pull to lift it 2 m?
1000 ÷ 5 = 200 N, and 5 × 2 = 10 m.
What each step is for
one pulley: Many students expect any pulley to make lifting easier. Committing first makes the result stick: a single fixed pulley only changes direction, like an idler gear. Each wrong option is a real slip: halving, or the turning wheel helping.
Try: add ropes: One rope fails at 150 N; adding ropes that hold the bottom block until it lifts settles the size question, and the rope pulled is reported, so students meet the cost before the rule.
Worked example: count the ropes: The worked example gives two rules from one count: pull = load ÷ supporting ropes, rope pulled = height × supporting ropes, and shows work in = work out. The faded example uses 6 ropes. Mia counts the rope she pulls, planted after the method.
Vary: choose a system: Students reason from the brief to the fewest ropes, then connect the fixed pulley back to the idler gear: a mechanism can change direction without changing force.
pulleys: Count the supporting ropes, divide for the pull, multiply for the rope, and the same trade as levers and gears.
a brief that needs four ropes: Writing a brief with a given answer reverses the reasoning: the load ÷ the pull must be more than 3 and no more than 4.
Where it leads
Next: the Capstone projects (Physical computing) include a lift and a winch where these trade-offs meet a motor.
Real examples: cranes, sailing boats (a mainsheet), flagpoles, window blinds, gym machines, rescue hauling systems.